Video: A Nation’s Shame: 95-Year-Old War Veteran Evicted to Make Way for Migrant Arrivals
A Nation’s Shame: 95-Year-Old War Veteran Evicted to Make Way for Migrant Arrivals
Frank Tammaro is a 95-year-old Korean War veteran who has lived at the Island Shores Senior Residence nursing home in Staten Island, New York for some time. However, he recently received devastating news when he was informed by the facility that he had to vacate his room with less than two months’ notice.
The reason given was that the nursing home was being converted to house undocumented migrants. Over 200 beds that were previously occupied by elderly residents like Tammaro would now be used to accommodate the influx of migrants arriving in New York City.
Tammaro expressed his frustration with the short notice period, saying “One day there was a notice on the board, I think that gave us a month and a half to find out where we were going to go.” He was worried that without his daughter’s help, he would have ended up “on the curb”.
Stress on New York City’s resources and infrastructure
New York City has seen over 113,000 undocumented migrants arrive since last year, with another 233,000 recorded crossing the southern border in August alone. This dramatic increase has strained the city’s resources and infrastructure.
Mayor Eric Adams has warned that the costs of housing and supporting migrants could reach $15 billion over the next three years. This is equal to the entire budgets of the city’s sanitation, fire and parks departments combined.
As a result, library hours, programs for seniors and daycare for children have been cut as the city tries to find the funding. Over 100 hotels in the city have been converted into temporary shelters, including the Roosevelt Hotel which is now housing around 3,000 migrants.
Controversy over prioritizing migrants over citizens
The eviction of elderly residents from the Staten Island nursing home to make way for migrants touched a nerve. Representative Nicole Malliotakis criticized the “backwards” priorities of the city, saying tax dollars should not be used to house foreign citizens over its seniors and veterans.
She pointed out that while the intentions may have been good, the way it was handled showed little respect or care for the vulnerable elderly residents who were given little time to find new accommodations. Many would have struggled without family support networks.
Tammaro echoed these sentiments, saying it was “disgraceful” how residents were treated. While he understood the problems faced by migrants, questions are being raised over whether priorities should lie with citizens over foreign nationals in allocating limited housing resources.
A complex issue with valid arguments on both sides
This situation highlights the challenging realities faced by many cities grappling with mass migration. There are reasonable perspectives on both sides of the debate.
On one hand, most agree that vulnerable groups like the elderly and veterans deserve respect and support from their community for their service and contributions. Upending their lives with little warning seems cruel.
However, cities also must help refugees and asylum seekers, who come seeking safety and new lives. Turning them away could mean sending people back to dangerous situations.
With needs overwhelming resources, there are no easy answers. Both compassion for citizens and migrants are important values to balance. More open communication and longer transition periods may have mitigated some concerns in this case.
Overall, it shows how massive shifts in migration can deeply impact communities in complex ways socially and economically. As crises continue, developed nations must find humane, sustainable policies that consider all sides of such debates.
The eviction of 95-year-old veteran Frank Tammaro from his nursing home in Staten Island sparked an intense debate. While caring for vulnerable groups and refugees are both important priorities, the way this transition was handled drew valid criticism.
Sudden large-scale changes deeply impact the lives of people, especially the elderly who have fewer support systems. Greater transparency, coordination and longer adjustment periods may have softened the blow in this difficult situation with no straightforward answers.
As migration crises put unprecedented pressure on cities and social programs, all sides deserve to be heard and no groups should find themselves abruptly discarded. Future policies must balance human rights and economic realities in a manner that respects all communities.
read more news here